Last year, while CC and I were sharing close quarters in a VW van, we got chatting one night about whether our expectations of men in relationships were unreasonably high. Should we settle for someone who is good enough?
According to Lori Gottlieb, yes, we should.
In 2007, she wrote an article for The Atlantic Magazine to this end, stating: …’every woman I know—no matter how successful and ambitious, how financially and emotionally secure—feels panic, occasionally coupled with desperation, if she hits 30 and finds herself unmarried.’
She then continued, ‘Oh, I know—I’m guessing there are single 30-year-old women reading this right now who will be writing letters to the editor to say that the women I know aren’t widely representative, that I’ve been co-opted by the cult of the feminist backlash, and basically, that I have no idea what I’m talking about. And all I can say is, if you say you’re not worried, either you’re in denial or you’re lying. In fact, take a good look in the mirror and try to convince yourself that you’re not worried, because you’ll see how silly your face looks when you’re being disingenuous.’
You’re going to have to take my word for it that I don’t share her view.
Lots of people have written their objections to this, and the argument about whether a woman should settle or hold out for something ‘better’ has risen its head into the public debate again because there is now a full-length version of this article, a book called:

The premise seems to be, that marriage is more important than love, and that the security it offers should be grasped when you are young and have the opportunity to grasp it. You have a lifetime of marriage to work out the niggles. A husband is useful as a means to have children and someone to share the childcare with.
‘If you rarely see your husband—but he’s a decent guy who takes out the trash and sets up the baby gear, and he provides a second income that allows you to spend time with your child instead of working 60 hours a week to support a family on your own—how much does it matter whether the guy you marry is The One?’ she argues.
Erm, possibly because marriage can’t just be about kids and when they’ve grown up and left home, what are you left with?
Although I agree that the older I get, and the clearer I become about who I am and what my aspirations are, what I’m looking for in a relationship becomes more exacting, it’s also perhaps based on things that are more fundamentally important and less flippant.
For example, when I was 19, I had a notional idea that it would be great to marry someone who had studied science, because I was studying arts and they would know something different to me. Now I really don’t care. I’d rather be with someone who was kind, for example.
So I agree that if you’re going to rule someone out for something superficial then you’re a fool.
But if ’settling’ means choosing to be with someone FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIFE who you do not love, but thought would make a good match because he is financially stable and would help you create a good context in which to have children, then ’settling’ seems a little mercenary to me.
And when I think of the guys, lovely as some of them were, who if I had decided to take Gottlieb’s advice I could have settled with in my twenties, I can’t help but suspect that we would both probably be fairly miserable now.
When any of my friends’ relationships come to an end, more often than not it’s because there was a fundamental incompatibility that meant that relationship would never work without belittling or diminishing one or other of them. Relationships need compromise, yes, but not to the extent that one person loses themselves to a dominant other (or do I have a mistaken/idealised view of parity?). We would always say to them – ‘It’s the right thing. He/she’s not good enough for you.’
Which means that Lori Gottlieb may be correct about choosing to marrying Mr Good Enough. It actually comes down to how you define ‘good enough’.
But I don’t agree with her that marriage is the ultimate goal. How soulless! And how perjorative that is to people who are unmarried for whatever reason?
Call me naive, or suggest that I do protest too much, but as far as I’m concerned love is the goal, and although it shows itself in different forms, if I love my family and my friends, and am loved in return, then I will have lived a satisfying and purposeful life. Married or not.














Recent Comments